lxy70713

I agree with you that it is taking too long asking for refund. It is indeed a lesson learned. But, I would like to see people's thoughts on the inaccurate descripion from the dealer. Not sure if it helps both coins worth around 5K each. These are not everyday coins, I won't be able to tell if there are any wear on the high points when I receive them in first place.

Thanks for your contribute. Not sure what do you mean by legal basis. Both coins were sold to me in Unc condition. But they turned out to be Extra fine or extremely fine according the grading company. I understand many people are not a big fan of these company, however, at least we have someone to rely on when it comes Numismatic coins which do not see it everyday. I bought both coins based the my past dealing with the dealer as we as the condition of coins. I understand grade can be very subjective. But when it comes professional dealer, giving an accurate and non bias grade, it is not too much to ask.

I am looking for advice from any members who bought high value coins and decide to return the coin because the grade is not accurate. About 5-6 months ago, I bought 2 high value coins from a reputable dealer which we had good dealings before. Both coins were sold to me with clear photos and with Unc condition in description. Both coins were sent to NGC for grading in last December and rencently came back as PF58 and AU58 which was unexpected. Am I realistic to expect both coins to be PF62 and MS62, or as the dealer said grading is a very personal thing which he disagree the results from NGC and ask me hold on for a few years to get my money back? Would anyone ask for a full refund if you were the buyers? I was hoping to get any opinions from some dealers in the group for my own knowledge. Thanks in advance

Thank you

I am looking to grade some old silver coins between 1817 - 1927 through NGC. IE. Crown or Half Crown. Which will be the correct tier to submit. Standard or Economy please? Thanks in advance