Red spots and slabs? Remove or not

[rob6]

I'm looking for some advice from members with more experience than myself, and was hoping someone could give some opinions and thoughts. I have a few PCGS graded, silver coins with red spots and minor toning, I knew about this before I bought them, and was happy with the purchase.  Do you think there is any benefit to leave them in the slabs, as to be honest i hate them, but obviously don't want to reduce the value by a huge margin.

I understand the need for protection on graded, and high quality coins, but that value seems to be lost if they are marked like this?

What would be your thoughts on the subject?

[richatthecroft]

Presumably Gold coins you are talking about?

 

[Au79]

You can consider if cost is not the issue

https://www.ngccoin.com/ncs-conservation/

https://www.pcgs.com/restoration

 

[rob6]

1 hour ago, richatthecroft said:

Presumably Gold coins you are talking about?

 

No, silver eagles mostly.

[kimchi]

I've got a batch of red-spotted silver here too (Niue stuff from Goldsilver) that I keep meaning to have a proper look at when I have time (I'd thought they might be fakes) so will follow this thread with interest.

[Au79]

It appears the coins inherit its traits from the beginning before everything else. 😑

https://www.pcgs.com/silver-coins-spot-policy